1. St. Louis Rams: Sam Bradford, QB, Oklahoma
The consensus choice here is Suh, and it’s certainly true that St. Louis needs help on its d-line, especially if it wants to see some return on its previous d-line investments. It’s also true that in a number of respects, not the least of which is experience in a pro-style offense, Jimmy Clausen is the better pick. Bradford, however, has extraordinary accuracy and much better arm strength than his rival Colt McCoy; he’s also a huge improvement over Clausen in terms of not being an enormous prick. The NFL’s bust rate is directly related to work ethic and leadership ability, and Bradford has both in spades. Neither Bradford nor Clausen is going to have the immediate impact of a Matt Ryan, and the very height of their potential is Aaron Rodgers, not Peyton Manning. Like Rodgers, Bradford would benefit immensely from sitting and learning a system (not to mention getting some offensive weapons and protection), a luxury he won’t have.
He’s the best option regardless, and while he’ll suffer through some rough early years, he has the potential to be the face of the franchise in a few years.
Other Possibilities: Jimmy Clausen, QB, Notre Dame; Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska
2. Detroit Lions: Ndamukong Suh, DT, Nebraska
Suh and Gerald McCoy, like Glenn Dorsey and Sedrick Ellis two years before them, increasingly seem like a “1 vs. 1a” in terms of potential. Unlike those two, Suh and McCoy don’t have a devastating injury (Dorsey’s chop block) and documented troubles handling the run (Ellis) between them. Suh would provide much-needed help on the interior of Detroit’s line, which has to be one of the league’s worst. They could also use Berry or Okung here, but safeties never get taken in the top three and Coach Schwartz has been vocal in his support of veteran left tackle Jeff Backus.
Other Possibilities: Gerald McCoy, DT, Oklahoma; Eric Berry, S, Tennessee